Your German tax assessment says “vorläufig” or “unter Vorbehalt der Nachprüfung”. Should you wait to pay until the tax office has finally finished? That can be a costly misunderstanding. These terms mainly concern whether an assessment can be amended. Whether and when money must be paid needs a separate check. This guide explains the German Fiscal Code, AO, and a process for an assessment you have actually received.
1. Separate assessment, payment accounting and open questions
A tax assessment determines a tax under section 155 AO. First check the person concerned, tax type, period and assessed amount. Section 157 requires, in particular, the tax type, amount, taxpayer and information on remedies. Do not automatically confuse assessed tax with the amount still to transfer: review the payment accounting, credited advance payments and stated refund or additional payment. Compare the figures with your return and the explanations. A request for missing documents is a different matter from an assessment.
2. Review reservation: An amendment remains possible
Section 164 AO permits assessment before the case has been finally examined. While the reservation remains effective, the assessment may be revoked or amended; you may also request an amendment. “Reservation” therefore does not mean the assessment has no effect. Nor does it promise that every query will be processed automatically or all objection deadlines remain open. Record the wording, specific discrepancy and correction you want to clarify. Payment remains a separate question.
3. Provisional: Read the specified scope carefully
Section 165 AO permits provisional assessment under particular conditions. Its scope and reason must be stated. Read the explanations: which point is open, and why? A provisional note does not automatically make every figure provisional. Nor is it an automatic payment pause. Suspension of an assessment and suspension of enforcement are separate issues. If you suspect another error, do not assume the provisional note will eventually resolve it too.
4. Due date: Record the payment issue separately
The relevant tax legislation determines when payment is due (section 220 AO). There is no single payment period for every letter and tax type. Mark the specified date and check the payment accounting for an outstanding balance. Clarify discrepancies early with the tax office or a tax adviser instead of waiting solely because the assessment is provisional. Keep the payment date and a possible objection deadline as two different tasks. Reviewing the amount does not replace organising payment.
5. Objection: No automatic halt to collection
An objection against a tax assessment generally must be lodged within one month of notification (section 355 AO). Read the remedy information and have the starting date clarified if uncertain; do not simply use the printed letter date. Under section 361 AO, an objection generally does not halt tax collection. Suspension of enforcement is a separate question subject to conditions. Applying does not mean it has been granted. Alongside the objection, explicitly clarify what applies to payment until a decision is made. Also check possible interest consequences: section 237 AO provides for suspension interest to the extent that the relevant objection or appeal ultimately fails.
6. If funds are short: Check deferral specifically
Deferral is different from challenging an assessment’s content. Under section 222 AO the tax office may defer all or part of a claim if collection at maturity would cause substantial hardship and the claim does not appear jeopardised by deferral. It should generally be granted only on application and against security. Statutory exclusions also apply, particularly in connection with withheld tax amounts. Discuss early whether your specific case qualifies. A granted deferral generally carries interest under section 234 AO; check the cost and any special circumstances. Prepare the amount, reason for payment difficulties and a workable proposal. Asking for instalments or more time is not already an approved deferral.
Example: A provisional issue and different business expenses
A self-employed person receives an assessment with a provisional note about one issue. The business-expense figure also differs from the submitted return. She reads the explanations, compares records and has the difference checked. She does not assume the provisional note covers this point automatically. She deals with the stated additional payment separately from a possible objection. If requesting payment relief, she does not simply wait for supposed automatic consent.
Assessment checklist
- Check tax type, person, period and assessed amount.
- Distinguish payment accounting from the actual outstanding balance.
- Read the reason and scope of provisional status or review reservation.
- Identify specific differences from your return and records.
- Record payment and remedy deadlines separately.
- Do not treat suspension or deferral as approved merely because you applied.
Common mistakes include waiting for a “final” assessment, confusing an objection with a payment pause and copying a deadline from another letter. Our tax number, tax ID and VAT ID overview helps identify your records. If a deadline has already passed, use the missed tax-office deadline guide and seek appropriate support. This process does not replace examination of your particular assessment.
Official sources
- Section 155 AO: Tax assessment
- Section 157 AO: Form and content of the assessment
- Section 164 AO: Reservation of subsequent review
- Section 165 AO: Provisional assessment and its scope
- Section 220 AO: Due dates
- Section 222 AO: Deferral conditions and limits
- Section 355 AO: Objection deadline
- Section 361 AO: Suspension of enforcement
- Section 234 AO: Deferral interest
- Section 237 AO: Possible suspension interest
Photo: Ron Lach / Pexels · Pexels license