Skip to content
Languages
Two calculators beside euro banknotes and coins on a light surface

Starting a business

Sole trader, UG or GmbH: Compare work, capital and liability

Low share capital does not mean little work. Compare personal liability, formation steps and ongoing duties before choosing a German business structure.

·

Photo: olia danilevich on Pexels

You want to start on your own and are considering a sole proprietorship, UG or GmbH in Germany. The cheapest registration alone does not tell you who is liable for debts or how much work the first year involves. Compare three separate issues: formation requirements, available money and liability risk. This guide explains the basic German structures so you can prepare a concrete decision with suitable advice.

1. Describe your risk before choosing a company name

List the contracts you expect to sign, whether you will employ people and what damage your work could cause. A sole proprietorship has no separate corporation between you and the business. As IHK Rhein-Neckar explains, you are generally liable with business and private assets. Personal liability is therefore a central question. For a GmbH, company assets generally answer for company debts under section 13 GmbHG. This does not guarantee private protection in every situation. The period before commercial-register entry needs separate consideration.

2. Do not confuse a sole-trader start with no formalities

A sole proprietorship does not involve creating a separate corporation. You must still clarify trade or tax registration and any professional authorisation. Commercial-register duties also do not depend simply on the label “sole trader”. Sections 1 and 2 HGB distinguish, in particular, by the nature and scale of the commercial business and possible voluntary registration. A blanket instruction that every solo founder must first enter the commercial register is wrong.

3. Separate GmbH capital from available cash

A GmbH’s statutory minimum share capital is €25,000 under section 5 GmbHG. This is not a flat formation fee. For formation solely through cash contributions, at least one quarter of each share must be paid before applying for registration, and the total must reach at least half the statutory minimum: €12,500 (section 7 GmbHG). This does not reduce the agreed capital or remove the remaining contribution obligation. Contributions in kind have their own requirements. Also budget for actual expenses and a reserve: rent, equipment, insurance and the period before customers pay. Plan for real operations as well as the statutory minimum.

4. Do not treat the UG as an informal one-euro solution

A UG (haftungsbeschränkt) may be formed below the GmbH minimum capital. Its capital must be paid in full before applying for registration, and contributions in kind are excluded (section 5a GmbHG). A statutory reserve is also required: one quarter of annual net profit after deducting a loss carried forward from the previous year. Low nominal capital removes neither formation costs nor operating funding needs. The reserve rule does not automatically turn the company into a GmbH at a particular bank balance.

5. Sequence the notary, register and first contract

Both UG and GmbH require notarised articles of association. The simplified model protocol under section 2 GmbHG is available only within the statutory conditions, including no more than three shareholders and one managing director. It does not replace registration. Before entry, the GmbH does not yet exist as such; people acting in its name beforehand are personally and jointly and severally liable under section 11 GmbHG. Clarify who signs your first lease or customer contract and at which formation stage.

6. Include the first year’s workload

Compare not just formation, but ongoing bookkeeping, annual accounts, advice, register procedures and your own time. A UG does not automatically have simplified accounting; section 5a GmbHG itself requires annual accounts with a balance sheet. Ask for the obligations and likely costs to be explained for your expected business volume. The German VAT exemption scheme for small businesses (Kleinunternehmerregelung) concerns VAT; it is not an additional legal structure. It does not turn a corporation into a sole proprietorship or replace a check of other duties. The tax-registration questionnaire guide helps you organise the separate tax-registration step.

Two different starting points

A founder working alone with manageable contracts considers whether a straightforward sole-trader start fits her risk. Another plans larger contractual commitments and wants to bring in partners; a corporation and carefully drafted articles may matter more to him. Both need a cash-flow plan. Neither should decide only on nominal capital or leave the start of liability protection unchecked.

Documents for your decision

  • Record actual risks and planned contracts.
  • Check trade registration, professional access and the register separately.
  • Distinguish capital, formation costs and operating reserves.
  • Clarify responsibility before registration.
  • Budget for ongoing duties and advice.
  • Document the decision, reasons and open questions.

Common mistakes include ignoring personal liability when starting alone, choosing a UG solely for low capital and confusing the small-business VAT scheme with a legal structure. Discuss liability and contracts with appropriate legal advice or a notary, and tax organisation with a tax adviser. The right choice depends on your particular plans.

Official sources

Photo: olia danilevich / Pexels · Pexels license

Organise your office digitally

With Motorica you create invoices, quotes and receipts – and keep deadlines in view.

Discover Motorica   Knowledge